Each call is tested in actual hunting conditions. Every call is subjected to the same test at the same location. Weather can play a minor factor in testing, but should not affect overall performance. I’m not a scientist, nor are my tests bulletproof — they are only intended to give you a better idea of what you’re getting if you spend the money.
Manufacturers publish their own specifications — the FOXPRO digital game call line, the Lucky Duck Revolt 2.0 and the ICOtec game call range all list sound counts, battery ratings and a claimed remote range. Every one of those numbers comes from the company selling the call. None of them test against each other, and none of them publish what happens in wind. That gap is the reason for the method below.
Each call finishes with a score out of a possible 100: ten criteria, ten points each.
How the calls are tested
Volume tests. The units are tested at 1 meter, approximately 40 inches from the speaker of the call. Because you cannot test the same sound on all units, the volume tests cannot be replicated exactly for each call. Each review specifies the sound that achieved the highest volume.
Remote tests. The units are set in the same location as all previous units. I mark off 25, 50, 75, and 100 yards and run initial responsiveness tests at those distances. Once the call passes or fails the initial tests, I run further tests to determine the quality of the remote range. The area has sage brush between the call and the remote to replicate the field conditions a hunter actually faces.
The 10 areas scored
- Caller design — How well does the call function? Can you use the call without a remote? I like units that don’t need one, in case of a lost remote. How large is the unit? I do not like a large unit that folds out into a massive distracting blob. Small and compact is best. What are the batteries, power requirements, and battery storage like?
- Call volume — How loud is the unit? Will it have the volume to carry on a windy day? Loud doesn’t always mean better, but it makes a big difference in wind or snow, where volume helps carry the sound.
- Sound quality — Some calls boast extreme volume but their sound quality is terrible. How good are the actual sounds on the unit? This is based on the standard sounds that ship with it, and the overall quality coming through the speaker. Some brands have high quality sounds that still come out different depending on the speaker, amplifier, or build.
- Portability — Based primarily on what the unit and remote weigh. How easy is it to carry in the field and handle the remote?
- Product build quality — How will this unit hold up in the field? Is it rugged or poorly built? Will you expect it to last, or have pieces and buttons fall off?
- Remote design — Is it built with a hunter in mind? How readable is the screen or printed text? Will it cause distractions in the field? Can you carry it on a lanyard?
- Remote functionality — Is it easy to use in the field? This is primarily user experience: how easy is it to play a sound, adjust the volume, or mute the call? Are the buttons easy to press? Is it intuitive, or does it take a PhD to use?
- Remote range — How well does it perform in hunting conditions? How far away can you expect to use this remote? 100 yards or more scores a 10.
- Pricing competitiveness — Based on the price range and comparable callers in that range.
- Best selling feature — Unique to each unit: what’s the best thing about it?
Calls tested so far
- Lucky Duck Revolt 2.0 — scoring in progress
- Foxpro Deadbone — 84/100
More reviews are added as calls come through the rotation. For the shortlist of what I’d actually buy today, see the best coyote call, or the full coyote hunting gear list for everything else that goes in the bag.